Lyle Menendez Makes His Case Before California Parole Board

SAN DIEGO (AP) - Lyle Menendez, 57, appeared online before the California Board of Parole Hearings on August 23, 2025. He is seeking release over 35 years after he and his brother Erik were convicted of killing their parents in 1989.

His hearing commenced at 8:30 a.m. from the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego. Menendez is up before a new panel after his Friday appearance. This group is not the same as the board that denied parole to his younger brother just a day earlier. Lyle’s hearing, just like Erik’s, looks at whether he poses a risk to public safety. This is key since he is resentenced to 50 years to life, with a chance for parole.

During the proceeding, board commissioners examined:

• Menendez has had some issues in prison. His infractions are said to be fewer than Erik’s, but they remain significant.
• His remorse and acceptance of responsibility stand in contrast to the prosecutors’ claim. They argue he hasn’t fully grasped the seriousness of his crimes.
• More than a dozen relatives testified in favor of Menendez’s release. They focus on his rehabilitation and how he positively influences others.
• Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman opposes parole. He argues that the brothers have told a “litany of lies” about their motives. He believes the violent nature of the murders weakens their self-defense claims.

Parole Commissioner Robert Barton, who led Erik’s hearing, said Thursday that the original crime’s severity mattered less than the applicant’s behavior in prison. ““Actions speak louder than words,” Barton said. He denied Erik Menendez release, citing serious prison rule breaches and his infraction history as key reasons.

Menendez’s supporters feel hopeful. They highlight his educational successes, such as his new college degree, and his long history of good behavior. His attorney, Mark Geragos, claims Lyle’s violations are like Erik’s. He argues it would be unfair for one brother to be paroled while the other isn’t.

The board will discuss its decision soon. This will decide if Lyle Menendez can leave prison or stay for at least three more years before he can seek parole again.