Love Island USA Winners Amaya Espinal and Bryan Arenales Spark Split Rumors Following Reunion Unfollow

Los Angeles, CA (August 26, 2025) - Rumors of a breakup between Love Island USA season 7 champions Amaya Espinal and Bryan Arenales intensified Monday after fans and media outlets noticed the pair had unfollowed each other on Instagram and shared cryptic social-media posts hinting at relationship troubles.

During the Peacock reunion special that aired August 25, co-host Andy Cohen confronted Bryan directly about allegations he cheated on Amaya when they left the villa. “Chris, you were out with Bryan on the night of the alleged cheating,” Cohen said, to which Bryan admitted, “I had a lapse in judgment,” while insisting the encounter was part of a paid hosting gig and not disloyalty. Amaya stood by him on stage, declaring, “I have complete confidence in our bond” and affirming that they had worked through the rumors privately.

Nevertheless, fans began investigating both stars’ Instagram activity after noticing that they no longer follow one another, a classic indicator of a split among high-profile couples. As of August 25, neither Amaya nor Bryan follow the other, though their Instagram feeds still feature posts of the two together. In the 48 hours leading up to and following the reunion, Amaya reposted TikTok videos with captions such as “how it feels when you know you have to leave him alone” and “when I finally pick myself back up and never let my walls down like that again,” further stoking speculation of an emotional rift.

Neither star has issued an official statement confirming a breakup. Both continue to maintain individual professional projects-Amaya with a new modeling contract and Bryan developing a fitness-coaching brand-which industry experts suggest may add pressure to their relationship outside the villa environment.

With no formal confirmation, fans remain divided. Some point to the unfollow as definitive proof of a split, while others believe the public gesture may simply reflect post-reunion stress rather than a definitive end to their romance. As of today, neither Amaya Espinal nor Bryan Arenales has addressed these recent social-media moves directly.