Patel Blames Acosta for “Original Sin” in Epstein Case During Senate Hearing

Lead FBI Director Kash Patel told the Senate Judiciary Committee on September 16 that the “original sin” in prosecuting Jeffrey Epstein was former U.S. Attorney Alex Acosta’s limited 2006 investigation and plea deal.

Nut Graf Patel’s direct criticism of Acosta-a Trump Cabinet member who negotiated Epstein’s non-prosecution agreement-signals a strategic shift as Republicans and Democrats alike press for transparency in the long-delayed release of court documents and prepare for Acosta’s voluntary testimony before the House Oversight Committee on September 19.

Key Assertions and Reactions

“Original Sin” Defined

  • Patel argued that Acosta’s initial case relied on a narrow set of search warrants that hamstrung future federal probes and sealed critical evidence under protective orders.
  • He maintained that if he had led the FBI in 2006, a broader investigation would have prevented subsequent delays and secrecy.

Bipartisan Calls for Transparency

  • Senators pressed Patel to release all non-sealed Epstein files.
  • Republican Sen. John Kennedy warned, “This issue’s not gonna go away,” demanding disclosure of any individuals Epstein trafficked and decried ongoing limitations under court orders.
  • Democrats similarly urged fuller document production, citing public interest and the need to restore trust.

Political Implications

  • Patel’s remarks mark the first time a prominent Trump appointee publicly blamed Acosta, who resigned as labor secretary in 2019 amid backlash over the Epstein deal.
  • The House Oversight Committee’s decision to allow Acosta’s voluntary appearance underscores rising tensions over the case’s handling and the Trump administration’s legacy on law enforcement matters.

Looking Ahead: Acosta’s Testimony

Alex Acosta is scheduled to meet with the House Oversight Committee on September 19. Observers will watch whether he defends his 2008 plea agreement and how lawmakers leverage Patel’s critique to demand accountability and broader document release.