Critics Split on Justin Tipping’s Football Horror “HIM” in Early Reviews

In its opening weekend, Justin Tipping’s football-themed horror thriller “HIM” drew praise for its bold visuals and lead performances but condemnation for its uneven narrative and tonal shifts. Early reviews from major outlets on September 19 reveal a film whose striking style often outpaces its substance.

A Visceral Spectacle Missing Coherence Critics agree that “HIM” is relentlessly stylish. CinemaBlend hailed its “visually audacious” execution and strong turns from Tyriq Withers and Marlon Wayans. Variety applauded its “gripping and surreal cinematic experience” and commentary on the brutal cost of athletic fame. Yet RogerEbert.com called it “putrid and hollow,” arguing its body-horror elements and religious motifs feel “ham-fisted and rushed.” The Hollywood Reporter warned the film “devolves into a surreal phantasmagoria” that overwhelms any chilling momentum.

Performances Anchor the Chaos Marlon Wayans, as veteran QB Isaiah White, earned near-universal nods. Screen Rant dubbed his turn “the only thing keeping the film together,” while The New York Times praised his “layered portrayal of a corrupt mentor.” Tyriq Withers also received acclaim for conveying both innocence and steel, though some reviewers lamented the distance the script keeps from his backstory.

Narrative Imbalance and Unresolved Threads Multiple critics highlighted a disjointed third act. Mashable and IGN cited an abrupt tonal shift and “disconnected” climax that leaves key questions unanswered. AP News noted the confined setting underscores the film’s themes but criticized its retreat from the broader football world. Vulture summed up the consensus: “A wild spectacle of male fantasy, but hollow inside.”

Context and Expectations Backed by producer Jordan Peele, “HIM” was anticipated as a genre-bending entry in Halloween season. With a runtime under 100 minutes, the film’s breakneck editing and dense symbolism aimed to subvert sports-film conventions. Yet, as critics point out, clarity-not ambiguity-is essential in satire.

Box Office Outlook Despite mixed reviews, the Peele name and combination of horror and sports may drive curious audiences to theaters. “HIM” launches wide today, and its financial fate will hinge on whether viewers connect with its audacious vision or find its narrative shortcomings too distracting.